Structural icing: conditions, supercooled water & ice types
Structural icing = ice building on airframe in flight. Needs both at once (TC AIM AIR 2.12.3.1):
- Visible moisture: cloud, rain, drizzle
- Temperature at or below 0 °C
Water is supercooled: liquid below 0 °C until it touches aircraft and freezes.
Supercooled water (AWH 20.2):
- Does not freeze on its own until about −40 °C
- Droplet surface tension resists freezing: smaller and purer droplet = more supercooled
Cloud water by temperature (AWH 20.2):
| Temperature | Cloud water |
|---|---|
| 0 °C to −10 °C | Mostly liquid supercooled droplets |
| −10 °C to −20 °C | Mix of droplets and ice crystals |
| Below −20 °C | Almost entirely ice crystals; strong updraft can carry supercooled water down to −40 °C |
- Nearly all structural icing between 0 °C and −20 °C (AWH 20.3.4).
Ice types: drop size decides (TC AIM MET Table 2.4). Temperature and liquid water content also matter (TC AIM AIR 2.12.3.1).
| Clear (glaze) ice | Rime ice | |
|---|---|---|
| Drops | large, supercooled | small, supercooled |
| Freezing | slow, spreads back | instant, on contact (traps air) |
| Looks | hard, clear, glossy, smooth, heavy | opaque, milky white, rough, brittle, light |
| Found in | freezing rain | light drizzle |
| Hazard | worst: hard to remove, heaviest | lighter, easier to shed |
| Temp | favours warmer than −10 °C | favours colder than −15 °C (mixed ice in between, AWH 20.3.4) |
| Liquid water content | higher | lower |
- Mixed ice: both at once, from cloud holding a range of drop sizes.
- Cloud type sets liquid water: cumuliform most, stratiform least (AWH 20.3.4).
- Big drop: much unfrozen water runs back before setting, glazes a clear sheet.
- Small drop: freezes on landing, traps air between grains, white and crumbly.
Trap: cold air alone or cloud alone forms no structural ice; clear vs rime is set by drop size, not temperature alone.
References
- TC AIM AIR 2.12.3 (in-flight airframe icing: clear ice is the worst type)
- TC AIM AIR 2.12.3.1 (visible moisture and at-or-below-freezing requirement)
- AWH 20.2 (supercooled water, cloud-water temperature bands)
- AWH 20.3.4 (Icing Factors: temperature band; liquid water by cloud type)
- TC AIM MET 2.4 (Table 2.4, Icing Types: ice-type definitions by droplet size)